Opionons Please = Help Me Deceide!!

[Nick Irvine]

Partly inspired by steven's ice hockey site (thanks mate) I have deceided to do a similar stats site - a rival site to take all his business... little joke there steven!!

Unfortunatly I dont know a thing about ice hockey, so my stats site is a liverpool fc stats site (get the liverpool jokes in now!)

I have a few designs I cant deceide which one to take. Please, please let me know which on you like. Add to the poll or post your thoughts. Design 3 is my favourite.

Design 1:
http://www.lfcstats.co.uk/alterndesigns/1182993150_8362.jpg

Design 2:
http://www.lfcstats.co.uk/alterndesigns/finalpf4.jpg

Design 3:
http://www.lfcstats.co.uk/alterndesigns/lfc_preview.jpg

Design 4:
http://www.lfcstats.co.uk/alterndesigns/soccer.jpg

[Andrew Taylor]

I prefer number 3

[level200]

I like number 4

[Carl Shepherdson]

No. 4 for me too.

[steven21]

Number 3 for me. Going to start showing me up now. lol

[Mark Voss]

Number 3 for me too.

My son's gonna love this!

[siphilp]

I like 3 but 4 is nicer :S

[Doudar]

Shame it's Liverpool and not Man U :D

3 for me

[Ben Collier]

hmm...

Design three seems the favourite, however, I think it looks two old fashioned, whilst four or two are more with it.

They're all nicely done thought!

Ben

[boomers]

I prefered the header of number 3 but the design of number 4

[Mark Voss]

Shame it's Liverpool and not Man U :D
You can always rely on a scummer to moan ;-)

[sladmin]

Don't like number one much, looks a tad too simple. I like 3 but I should think people would find it hard to read the text. Can't you combine 2,3 and 4? If I would choose number 3

[steven21]

Nick, have you decided which look to go for?

[Nick Irvine]

Yeah, I have not agreeing to all your tastes im afraid. Have a look:
http://www.lfcstats.co.uk/new

Its good this design cos I can make my own headers, so i can put new signings on there, (such as torres) and new trophies! (prem title this season) keep refreshing the page and you'll see new ones, think ive got four on there at the moment.

[sladmin]

I like the design you've got on there, but I would say the navigation is a tad squashed ;)

[Mark Voss]

Yep - I quite like it too.

Just a couple of points:

Couldn't you use CSS rollovers for the navigation instead of JavaScript?

Why build the stats area at the bottom from divs instead of using a table?
(You'll also save yourself a lot of cross-browser display problems).